This is discussed in Lecture 1 on You Tube : |
"The Key to Soul Is Within The Missing Stopinder in the Food Octave" Dylan Stephens © 2018
|Text is from "Beelzebub's Tales to His Grandson" by G.I. Gurdjieff |
(Corrected errata from 1950 edition are underlined; the page numbers are shown).
The figures are from "In Search of the Miraculous" by P.D. Ouspensky
|Background of the Enigma of the Missing Stopinder|
* page 761|
"In Tetartocosmoses the following names were given to
This is my attempt to fix the enigma of the Food Octave where Gurdjieff has placed Exioehary (Testes: Sperm and Ovary:ovum) as the sixth note (6) 'la' of the Law of Seven when it is clearly intended as the seventh (7) 'ti' and "Resulzation" would by its name be the completed octave at (8) higher 'do', however when it is moved to its proper place, there is a missing center and substance at sixth note (6) 'la'.
To offer a solution to the problem, I have compared "In Search of the Miraculous" by P.D. Ouspensky, Chapter 9 The Table of Hydrogens and their production in the Food Octave with "Beelzebub's Tales to His Grandson" by G.I. Gurdjieff Chapter 39 The Holy Planet Purgatory.
Ouspensky's recollections of Gurdjieff from 1915 onwards are useful as a cross reference especially because Ouspensky was meticulous in his notes and, although the centers and substances are not defined as they are in Gurdjieff's book, they are located in a three storied structure of man namely upper floor (the head), middle floor (the chest) and bottom floor (the back and the lower part of the body). The Hydrogen substances are labeled as to density and are placed in their appropriate stories and thus it must be assumed that Gurdjieff knew what they were, but was holding back the information.
The three being foods are also shown as ordinary food, air and impressions. Air matches with Gurdjieff and Ouspensky's 'impressions' is a mere shadow of 'the assimilation of the cosmic substances,' but the point is clear that no higher beings will be created without 'conscious labors' and 'intentional suffering' which begins with consciousness or ‘being-Partkdolg-duty.'
In addition to inserting a substance at sixth note 'la', I have taken issue with Gurdjieff on his assignment of a lower vibrational substance for cerebrum over cerebellum. Humorously, this would be to say that only zombies get to heaven. Other than that I have reproduced the words exactly from Beelzebub's Tales and the page numbers correspond to the 1950 edition which is online here.
|First it is important to clear up another error in Chapter 39 The Holy Planet Purgatory|
concerning the definition of "Stopinder".
|In trying to solve the missing 'independent arising', one might try to place each 'independent arising' between the notes (gravity centers), but this is not correct.|
* page 750|
“The first of these fundamental primordial cosmic sacred
laws, namely, the law of Heptaparaparshinokh,
present-day objective cosmic science, by the way, formulates
in the following words:
“This sacred primordial cosmic law has seven deflections
or, as it is still otherwise said, seven ‘centers of
gravity’ and the distance between each two of these
* page 751
deflections or ‘centers of gravity’ is called a ‘Stopinder-of-the- sacred-Heptaparaparshinokh.’
In reference to Chapter 17 The Arch-Absurd, it can be seen that a Stopinder is not as stated in Chapter 39 above as|
"the distance between each two of these deflections or ‘centers of gravity’" but rather the center of gravity itself, thus 'do', 're', 'mi', 'fa', 'sol', 'la', 'ti'.
* page 139 Chapter 17 The Arch-Absurd:
“And so, my boy, the Omnipresent-Okidanokh obtains
its prime arising in space outside of the Most Holy Sun
Absolute itself, from the blending of these three independent
forces into one, and during its further involutions it
is correspondingly changed, in respect of what is called
the ‘Vivifyingness of Vibrations’ according to its passage
through what are called the ‘Stopinders’ or ‘gravity centers’
of the fundamental ‘common-cosmic sacred Heptaparaparshinokh.’
|Detailed Examination of the Food Octave comparing:|
Text of "Beelzebub's Tales to His Grandson" by G.I. Gurdjieff
with the figures from "In Search of the Miraculous" by P.D. Ouspensky.)
* page 753|
"And so, in consequence of the fact that for this new
system of functioning of the forces which until then
maintained the existence of the Most Most Holy Sun Absolute,
there were required outside of the Sun Absolute
corresponding sources in which such forces could arise
and from which they could flow into the presence of the
Most Most Holy Sun Absolute, our ALMIGHTY ENDLESSNESS
was just then compelled to create our now existing
Megalocosmos with all the cosmoses of different scales
and relatively independent cosmic formations present in
it, and from then on the system which maintained the
existence of the Sun Absolute began to be called Trogoautoegocrat.
"Our COMMON FATHER OMNI-BEING ENDLESSNESS, having
decided to change the principle of the maintenance of
the existence of this then still unique cosmic concentration
and sole place of HIS most glorious Being, first of
all altered the process itself of the functioning of these
two primordial fundamental sacred laws, and HE actualized
the greater change in the law of the sacred Heptaparaparshinokh.
"These changes in the functioning of the sacred Heptaparaparshinokh
consisted in this, that in three of its
Stopinders HE altered the what are called ‘subjective actions'
which had been until then in the Stopinders, in this
respect, that in one HE lengthened the law-conformable
successiveness; shortened it in another; and in a third,
* page 761|
"In Tetartocosmoses the following names were given to
these independent arisings:
(6) Incorrectly left out: Hormoneary (made up my me)
(7) Exioehary was (6) but is clearly (7)
(8) Resulzarion was (7) but is clearly (8) as converted Exioehary
|'do' (1) Protoehary (Ouspensky: H 768 lower (stomach-spine) story)|
"And if now, my boy, you satisfactorily grasp the succession
of the process of transformation of cosmic substances
by means of beings-apparatuses, into which these
cosmic substances enter as first being-food, then at the
same time you will approximately understand everything
concerning the chief particularity of the sacred law of
Heptaparaparshinokh as well as the processes of evolution
and involution of the other higher being-foods.
"When these evolving active elements, in their returning
ascent from the last Stopinder of the fundamental
common-cosmic Sacred Heptaparaparshinokh, enter into
the common presences of being-apparatuses as their first
being-food, they begin already from the mouth itself—
with the help of the processes of the second-grade law
* page 787
Harnelmiatznel, that is, owing to mixture and fusion according
to the ‘affinity of vibrations,' with the active elements
which have already evolved in the presences of the
beings and have acquired vibrations corresponding to the
subsequent Stopinders of the being-Heptaparaparshinokh—
to be gradually changed, and are transmuted this
time in the stomach of the beings into definite active elements
named ‘being-Protoehary,' which correspond in
their vibrations to the ascending fourth Stopinder of the
fundamental common-cosmic Heptaparaparshinokh.
|'re' (2) Defteroehary (Ouspensky: H 384 lower (stomach-spine) story)|
vibration' of being-Protoehary, passing—thanks again
only to the process Harnelmiatznel—over the whole of
what is called the ‘intestinal tract' and gradually evolving,
completedly acquires in consequence corresponding vibrations,
and is this time completely transmuted in what
is called the ‘duodenum' into ‘being-Defteroehary.'
|'mi' (3) Tritoehary (Ouspensky: H 192 middle (chest) story)|
Defteroehary' go to serve the planetary body itself and
also the local Harnelmiatznel in respect of the newly entering
food, but the other part, also by means of a process
of Harnelmiatznel of local character, continues its independent
evolution and is ultimately transmuted in beings
into the still higher definite substances which are called,
this time, ‘being-Tritoehary.'
"And this totality of cosmic substances, temporarily
crystallized in the common presences of ‘beings-apparatuses
which correspond in their vibrations to ‘being-Tritoehary,'
have as the gravity-center place of their concentration in
the presences of beings the, what is called, ‘liver.'
"It is just in this place of the being-Ansanbaluiazar
that the lower ‘Mdnel-In' of the Sacred Heptaparaparshinokh
is located, called the ‘mechano-coinciding-Mdnel-In,' and
therefore the substances of the being-Tritoehary
* page 788
cannot, only owing to the process ‘Harnelmiatznel,' independently
"Well then, owing to that change in the general functioning
of the primordial common-cosmic sacred law of
Heptaparaparshinokh, this totality of substances named
'being-Tritoehary' can in the given case evolve further
from this state only with the help of forces coming from
"That is why in this case, if this totality of substances
of ‘being-Protoehary' does not receive foreign help from
outside for its further evolution in the common presences
of the beings, then both this totality and all the
definite centers of gravity of the being-Ansanbaluiazar
crystallized up to it always involve back again into those
definite cosmic crystallizations from which they began
"For this help coming from outside, Great Nature in
the given case most wisely adapted the inner organization
of beings in such a manner that the substances which had
to enter into the common presences of beings for the
coating and feeding of their second being-bodies Kesdjan,
namely, that totality of cosmic substances which your favorites
call air, might at the same time serve as just such
a help coming from outside for the evolution of the substances
of the first being-food.
"The active elements which compose this second being-food
or air, and which enter into the presences of beings
also for evolution through this second being-food, beginning
from the nose of beings, gradually evolve with the
co-operation of various processes of Harnelmiatznel of local
character, and are also transmuted this time in the
what are called ‘lungs' of beings into Protoehary, but into
Protoehary called ‘Astralnomonian-Protoehary.'
"And then the substances of this ‘Astralnomonian-
Protoehary,' entering into the presences of beings for their
own evolution and having still in themselves, according to
* page 789
the Sacred Heptaparaparshinokh, all the possibilities of
evolving from their centers of gravity by the process of
Harnelmiatznel alone, mix with the totality of substances
of the first being-food which have already evolved up to
the third Stopinder of the Sacred being-Heptaparaparshinokh,
and further evolve together, and thus help these substances
of the first being-food to pass through the lower
'mechano-coinciding-Mdnel-In' and to be transmuted into
other definite substances, into ‘being-Tetartoehary,' and
the Astralnomonian-Protoehary' itself is transmuted into
the substances named ‘Astralnomonian-Defteroehary.'
"At this point in my explanations, you can have one
more clarifying example for a full understanding of the
difference between Autoegocrat and Trogoautoegocrat,
that is, of the difference between the former maintaining
system of the existence of the Sun Absolute when that system
was Autoegocratic, and the other system now called
Trogoautoegocratic which it became after the creation of
"If the transformation of substances through ‘beings-apparatuses'
proceeded according to the law of the Sacred
Heptaparaparshinokh when certain of its Stopinders were
not yet changed, that is, as it still functioned before the
creation of our now existing Megalocosmos, then the cosmic
substances composing the first being-food, entering
into such ‘apparatuses-cosmoses' for the local process of
evolution, would accomplish their ascent up to their
completing transmutation into other higher definite active
elements without any obstacle and without any help
coming from outside—merely by the process of Harnelmiatznel
alone, but now since the independent functioning
of this primordial sacred law has been changed
into a dependent functioning, the evolution or involution
in its changed Stopinders must always be dependent upon
external ‘extraneously caused' manifestations.
"In the given case, this extraneously caused help for
* page 790
the complete transmutation of cosmic crystallizations
through beings into higher crystallizations is the second
being-food, which has entirely different causes of its arising
and which must actualize entirely different cosmic results.
"I will some time later explain to you in detail how the
transformation of the substances of the second and third
being-foods proceeds in beings, but meanwhile note only
that these higher cosmic substances in beings are transformed
according to exactly the same principles as the
substances of the first being-food.
|'fa' (4) Tetartoehary (Ouspensky: H 96 middle (chest) story)|
to the Sacred Heptaparaparshinokh, the further
completing process of the transformation of the substances
of their first being-food proceeds in the presences
"And so ... the ordinary first being-food is thus gradually
transmuted in beings into definite substances called
'being-Tetartoehary,' which have in beings, just as of
course in your favorites, as the central place of their concentration
both of what are called the
Having swapped with (Piandjoehary:5) this should read:
"the ‘cerebellum,’ which in beings is also located in the head."
(Ouspensky has it in the middle (chest) story which is acceptable as it is also the spinal column.
In any case the cerebrum must be higher than cerebellum.)
|'sol' (5) Piandjoehary (Ouspensky: H 48 top (head) story)|
hemispheres of their head-brain goes unchanged to serve
the planetary body of the given being, but the other part
having in itself all the possibilities for independent evolution,
continues to evolve without any help coming from
outside; and mixing again by means of the process Harnelmiatznel
with previously formed higher substances already
present in the beings, it is gradually transmuted into
still higher definite being-active-elements called ‘Piandjoehary.'
"And these substances have as the central place of their
concentration in beings the, what is called, ‘Sianoorinam'
or, as your favorites call this part of their planetary body,"
* page 791
Having swapped with (Tetartoehary:4 assumed to be cerebrum) this should read:
"the 'hemispheres of their head-brain:'"
(thus ‘cerebrum' Piandjoehary:5 which is confirmed by Ouspensky as being in the top (head) story.
|"Soul-Protoehary" (Due to the presence of the third point of the triangle in the enneagram at the higher 'do')|
and in order to transform completedly
into new higher substances and in order to acquire vibrations
corresponding to the vibrations of the next higher
vivifyingness, namely, corresponding to the fifth Stopinder
of the fundamental process of the common-cosmic Sacred
Heptaparaparshinokh, it inevitably requires just that foreign
help which is actualized only in the presences of the
three-brained beings exclusively owing to those factors
mentioned by me more than once and which are manifested
in the ‘being-Partkdolg-duty,' that is, owing to just
those factors which our COMMON FATHER CREATOR ENDLESSNESS
consented to foreordain to be the means by
which certain of the Tetartocosmoses—as a final result of
their serving the purposes of the common-cosmic Iraniranumange—
might become helpers in the ruling of the
enlarged World, and which factors also until now serve as
the sole possible means for the assimilation of the cosmic
substances required for the coating and perfecting of the
higher being-bodies and which we at the present time call
'conscious labors' and ‘intentional suffering.'
* page 783
It is interesting, however, to notice that in the beginning,
namely, soon after the destruction of the functioning
of the organ Kundabuffer in the three-brained beings
breeding on this planet of yours, they also became aware
of these two higher being-foods, and then began to use
them with cognized intention, and certain beings of the
continent Atlantis of its latest period even began to consider
these same processes of the absorption of these
higher being-foods as the chief aim of their existence.
“The beings of the continent Atlantis then called the
second being-food Amarloos,’ which meant ‘help-for-the-moon,’
and they called the third being-food the ‘sacred
Amarhoodan,’ and this last word then signified for them
(It is interesting to note how Gurdjieff created the word 'Piandjoehary' and 'Kundabuffer' by reference to a map of the Amu Darya in Central Asia. There are two tributaries: the Panj (Pyandzh) River representing "Help for God" (since this is where the Sarmoung brotherhood was located) and the other being Kunduz River representing "Help for the Moon". - See Meetings with Remarkable Men).
|'la' (6): It is conjectured to be missing from Beelzebub's Tales.|
Called here: "Hormoneary" (word coined by me) (Ouspensky: H 24 middle (chest) story)
(Endocrine system: Hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal axis centered in the chest)
(Following Gurdjieff's announcement of the 'cerebellum': * page 791, which has been swapped with 'cerebrum' as shown in the previous section, there appears be a section that applies to the "missing Stopinder" shown in bold:)|
“Just these same substances in beings, according to the fifth deflection of the Sacred Heptaparaparshinokh, have the free possibility of giving, in the manifestations of the common presences of three-brained beings, results not similar but ‘opposite to each other.’ “That is why, in respect of these being-substances, the beings themselves must always be very, very much on their guard in order to avoid undesirable consequences for their entire whole. “From the
|'ti' (7) Exioehary (Ouspensky: H 12 lower (stomach-spine) story)|
|"'Hydrogen' si 12 is the 'hydrogen' which represents the final product of the transformation of food in the human organism. This is the matter with which sex works and which sex manufactures. It is 'seed' or 'fruit.'" & "And when they (all the cells of physical body) have become sufficiently saturated the matter si 12 begins to crystallize. The crystallization of this matter constitutes the formation of the 'astral body.'" "In Search of the Miraculous", pg 262,263)|
in the beings of the male sex, in what are called ‘testicles'
and in the beings of the female sex in what most of your
favorites call ‘ovaries,' which are the place of concentration
in the common presences of beings of the ‘being-
Exioehary,' which is for the beings themselves their most
sacred possession. "Just these same substances in beings, according to the
fifth deflection of the Sacred Heptaparaparshinokh, have
the free possibility of giving, in the manifestations of the
common presences of three-brained beings, results not
similar but ‘opposite to each other.'
"That is why, in respect of these being-substances, the
beings themselves must always be very, very much on
their guard in order to avoid undesirable consequences for
their entire whole.
(First part of paragraph beginning "From the cerebellum of beings"
and sentence beginning "You should know" is moved to (6))
"Only after this are the cosmic substances which enter
beings-apparatuses for the purpose of evolution, that is,
for the possibility of passing the lower Mdnel-In of the
fundamental common-cosmic ‘exchange of substances,'
transformed into that definite totality of cosmic substances—
which transformation is the lot of all beings in
general and also of your contemporary three-brained beings
who breed on the planet Earth in particular, for the
automatic justification of the sense and aim of their existence,
and this totality of cosmic substances is everywhere
|Higher 'do' (8) Resulzarion|
* page 791|
"And so, my boy, this totality of their first being-food
which results from the evolution in these beings-apparatuses,
* page 792
corresponds with its vibrations to the last Stopinder of
the being-Heptaparaparshinokh, and according to the
particularity of this Stopinder, it enters the
‘higher-intentionally-actualizing-Mdnel-In' of the law of
Heptaparaparshinokh; * skip to page 796
"Come now and let us talk about these ‘higher-perfected-
being-bodies,' that is about ‘souls,' who came
onto this holy planet Purgatory to which all my foregoing
explanations have referred.
"And so ... from the very beginning, when these
higher being-parts arose in this way and were perfected
* page 797
in beings to the required sacred gradation of Objective
Reason, that is to say, when in accordance with the lower
Mdnel-In of the Sacred Heptaparaparshinokh, the body-
Kesdjan was, thanks to the second being-food formed in
beings, and in accordance with the higher Mdnel-In of
the same sacred law, the third highest being-body was,
thanks to the third being-food, coated and perfected; and
when these completely perfected higher being-parts were
divided from the lower being-parts, then they were
deemed worthy to be immediately united with the Most
Most Holy Prime-Source and began to fulfill their Divine
Some followers of Ouspensky resolve the enigma of the Food Octave by starting 'Protoehary' at note 're' instead of 'do', but this is contradicted by page 787 because the 'fourth Stopinder of the fundamental common-cosmic Heptaparaparshinokh' would not begin at 're'.
Strangely, John Bennett insists that 'Exioehary' is meant to remain at (6) ("Talk's on Beelzbub's Tales, p. 99"). This is contradicted by page 791-792:
For those who still do no see a problem in the list of seven substances at the top, it is confirmed in his writings that (6) 'Exioehary' is at position 'ti' (See above paragraph) and (7) 'Resulzarion' would by its name imply that it represents the higher 'do'. This would mean that they should be labeled (7) and (8). 'Piandjoehary' can also be shown in the discussions about it to be at position 'sol' and therefore can remain at (5) as this is the position before the triangle on the left in the enneagram. This leaves (6) to be missing except for some mysterious pathway ‘Trnlva'.
I myself many times tried to resolve it by filling in these substances in the spaces between the notes, but this never seemed satisfactory. (I have spoken elsewhere of my question to the first line student Nyland about this, and the brush-off he gave me.)
There is one author (reference contained in Enneagram link) who claims that Gurdjieff purposefully left out the position 'la' in the Food Octave in "Beelzebub's Tales" in order to show the action of the enneagram. This is in spite of the fact that he taught this position to Ouspensky many years prior to this (see diagram in the section on 'la' above taken directly from "In Search of the Miraculous").
Although it is possible that Gurdjieff did map out "Beelzebub's Tales" according to the enneagram (given that there are only six voyages by Beelzebub's to the Planet Earth, instead of seven and given that there are only six enneagram points), it is perhaps merely a literary device. (See Outline of All and Everything).
The fact remains that the word enneagram is absent in "Beelzebub's Tales" especially in the Chapter 'Form and Sequence' where it certainly should have been mentioned. Although Gurdjieff does use the phrase "perpetual motion" (See "The System of Archangel Hariton") which might imply the enneagram (See "Mapping the Enneagram") and certainly used it widely in the dances he correographed called "Movements", this does seem point to its use in the Food Octave.
What is the real reason that the substance at 'la' is missing in the Food Octave? I would have expected that Ouspensky would have pointed out this discrepancy to Gurdjieff and then mentioned it in "In Search of the Miraculous", however, maybe he was never allowed to see "Beelzebub's Tales". I can only chalk it up to sloppiness on Gurdjieff's part and the syndrome of an "infallible leader that no one dares to question" that prevented someone from correcting his mistake, but most of all Gurdjieff's tendency to alienate those who could have assisted him.
|Text of "Beelzebub's Tales to His Grandson" by G.I. Gurdjieff|
(with my comments; my illustrations on the left)
(right hand figures from "In Search of the Miraculous" by P.D. Ouspensky.)
*In Search of the Miraculous" Chapter 10 Page 205
By comparing this with Beelezbub's Tales, it appears that both have a missing a cosmos.
* page 759|
“Here it is necessary to tell you that when this most
wise Divine actualization was finished, our triumphant
cherubim and seraphim then gave, for the first time, to all
the newly arisen actualizations those names which exist
even until today. Every ‘relatively independent concentration’
in general they then defined by the word ‘cosmos,’
and to distinguish the different orders of arising of these
* page 760
‘cosmoses,’ they added to this definition ‘cosmos’ a separate
“And all the results issuing from all the cosmic sources,
great and small, taken together, were also then named by
them the ‘common-cosmic Ansanbaluiazar.’
“It is interesting to remark that concerning this ‘common-
cosmic Ansanbaluiazar,’ present-day objective science
has also the formula: ‘Everything issuing from
everything and again entering into everything.’
“Independent names were then given also to all the, as they
are called, ‘temporarily independent crystallizations’ arising in
each of the innumerable cosmoses by the evolutionary and involutionary
processes of these fundamental sacred laws.
(Cosmoses reordered and grouped from highest to lowest)|
1. Holy Sun Absolute:
“And, namely, they named the Most Most Holy Prime-
Source Sun Absolute itself—‘Protocosmos.’
(1) The emanation of the Holy Sun Absolute,
Itself they called, as I have already told you,
’Theomertmalogos’ or ‘Word-God.’
2. galaxies: Milky Way:|
* page 748
“In the beginning, when nothing yet existed and when
the whole of our Universe was empty endless space with
the presence of only the prime-source cosmic substance
’Etherokrilno,’ our present Most Great and Most Most
Holy Sun Absolute existed alone in all this empty space,
* page 749
and it was on this then sole cosmic concentration that our
UNI-BEING CREATOR with HIS cherubim and seraphim had
the place of HIS most glorious Being.
“It was just during this same period of the flow of time
that there came to our CREATOR ALL-MAINTAINER the forced
need to create our present existing ‘Megalocosmos,’ i.e., our
* page 760
“And all those cosmoses, which together compose our
present World, began to be called the ‘Megalocosmos.’
“And then also our cherubim gave names, also existing
until now, to the emanations and radiations issuing from all
these cosmoses of different scales, by means of which the
process of the most great cosmic Trogoautoegocrat proceeds.
* page 761
(7) The common radiations of all the ‘Newly-arisen-second-order- Suns taken together they called ‘Polorotheoparl.’
3. Sun stars: Sun: |
* page 760
“Each newly arisen ‘Second-order-Sun’ with all its consequent
definite results they called ‘Defterocosmos.’
(5) The radiation of each separate Second-order-Sun, ’Mentekithzoin.’
4. solar systems: Solar System (Mesocosmos):|
* page 761
(6) The radiations of all the planets together of any solar system they called ‘Astroluolucizoin.’
5. planets: Earth:|
* page 760
“‘Third-order-Suns,’ i.e., those we now call ‘planets,’
they called ‘Tritocosmos.’
(3) The radiation of each planet separately they called ’Dynamoumzoin.’
6. three-brained beings: Humans:|
* page 760
and, finally, those formations of the
‘microcosmos’ and which also became concentrated on
the planets, this time thanks to the second-order cosmic
law called ‘mutual attraction of the similar,’ were named
‘Tetartocosmoses.’ * page 761
The radiations issuing from the ‘Tetartocosmoses’ they called ‘Hanbledzoin.’